Mind & Spirit
Mind

Ningning and the Other Self: Fame, the Mind, and the Dignity Behind the Avatar

aespa's Ningning left home at thirteen to train in Seoul. Her story says something about pressure, ADHD, online judgment, and the person no image can contain.

Shirley Xu·
Ningning and the Other Self: Fame, the Mind, and the Dignity Behind the Avatar

When aespa debuted in November 2020, the group arrived with a concept that sounded like science fiction. Each of the four members had a digital twin, an avatar, living in a virtual world. The name itself was built from that idea: "avatar" and "experience," joined to "aspect," meaning two sides. SM Entertainment described it as a story about "meeting another self and experiencing the new world."

It was a clever piece of marketing. It was also, without perhaps intending to be, a precise description of what fame does to a young person.

Every celebrity lives with another self. There is the person who wakes up, eats breakfast, misses home, and gets tired. And there is the image: the face on the billboard, the voice in the stadium, the name in the comment section, a figure that millions of strangers believe they know. For Ning Yizhuo, known to the world as Ningning, that second self arrived early, travelled fast, and has rarely been allowed to rest.

This is not a fan profile. It is a reflection on what her story can teach the rest of us about identity, pressure, the mind, and the dignity of a person that no image can contain.

A Voice from Harbin

Ningning was born on October 23, 2002, in Harbin, in China's far northeast, a city famous for its winters and its ice festival. She sang in public almost as soon as she could. In 2011, as a young child, she appeared on China's Got Talent. In 2015 she competed on the children's singing program Let's Sing Kids, and it was there that SM Entertainment noticed her.

In September 2016, at thirteen, she was introduced as a member of SM Rookies, the company's pre-debut training team. That meant leaving home for Seoul, a new language, and the famously demanding regimen of K-pop training: years of vocal lessons, dance practice, evaluations, and waiting. She trained for four years before debut.

It is worth pausing on that number. Four years, from the age of thirteen to almost eighteen, are the years in which most of us are slowly working out who we are. Ningning spent them working out who she would need to be on stage, in a country that was not yet home, with no guarantee that the work would lead anywhere.

When SM finally revealed her as aespa's third member in October 2020, the company introduced her as an "18-year-old Chinese member with an outstanding voice." Fans quickly agreed. Her voice, bright and agile and strong in the upper register, became one of the group's signatures.

Ningning singing on stage in a black and gold embroidered jacket, wearing a headset microphone

Ningning at the SYNK : PARALLEL LINE encore concert, March 2025. Photo: plumflower snow, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

The Girl and the Avatar

aespa debuted on November 17, 2020, with "Black Mamba." Its music video drew 21.4 million views in its first 24 hours, a record at the time for a K-pop group's debut. What followed was one of the fastest rises in the genre's history.

"Next Level" in 2021 became a phenomenon and later won Song of the Year at the Korean Music Awards. That November, aespa became the first Korean girl group to perform at the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade. In 2022 they played Coachella, and Time named them among its Next Generation Leaders. Their EP Girls reached number three on the US Billboard 200. In 2024, "Supernova" spent eleven weeks at number one on South Korea's main digital chart and won Song of the Year at both the 2024 MAMA Awards and the Melon Music Awards, and "Whiplash" became the group's first top-ten entry on the Billboard Global 200.

By any measure, it is an extraordinary run. Ningning has also built a life outside the group: a duet with Jay Park, "WYA," in 2023; a stint as a special mentor on the Chinese music competition The Next 2023; drama soundtracks; songwriting credits; and global ambassadorships with fashion houses, including Gucci in 2026.

But consider the concept again. aespa's members were introduced alongside digital versions of themselves, figures who could be designed, styled, and perfected. The idea was playful, but it raised a question that every person in the public eye eventually faces: when the world falls in love with your image, what happens to the person who is not an image?

Christianity has an answer to that question, and it is older than any avatar.

"For the LORD does not see as mortals see; they look on the outward appearance, but the LORD looks on the heart."

1 Samuel 16:7

The crowd sees the stage. God sees the girl from Harbin who left home at thirteen. Only one of those two ways of seeing is complete.

A Mind That Moves Fast

One of the most striking moments in Ningning's public life was not a performance. In 2023, appearing on Bam Home, the YouTube show hosted by GOT7's BamBam, she shared that she has ADHD. She described the stress it brings and how it makes focusing difficult, and she talked about the things that help her settle, like drawing and reading.

In another interview, with Vogue China, she mentioned that she had eye surgery as a child and can barely see with her right eye.

Neither disclosure was dramatic. Both were quietly brave. The idol industry prizes polish: perfect choreography, perfect skin, perfect composure. To say, in effect, my mind works differently, and my body has limits, is to step briefly out from behind the avatar and let people see a real person.

For many young viewers, that matters more than any chart record. ADHD is common, often misunderstood, and frequently treated as a character flaw rather than a difference in how the brain manages attention and impulses. When someone admired for her discipline says she lives with it, she makes it easier for others to name their own struggles without shame.

The Catholic tradition has always insisted that the human person is a unity of body and soul. Our minds are not machines that either work or fail; they are part of how God made each of us, with particular gifts and particular limits. A wandering attention does not make a person less faithful, less capable, or less loved. It means she, like every one of us, has to learn the shape of her own nature, and to work with it rather than against it.

When the Internet Becomes a Courtroom

In November 2025, a three-year-old post resurfaced. In 2022 Ningning had shared a video of a lamp; some users in Japan argued that its shape resembled the mushroom cloud of an atomic bomb, and that posting it was an insult to the victims of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The criticism spread rapidly. A petition urging the public broadcaster NHK to cancel aespa's appearance on its year-end Kōhaku Uta Gassen gathered more than 100,000 signatures, and a petition to keep her off Japanese television was viewed more than 100 million times on X.

NHK kept the performance on its schedule and stated that Ningning "had no intention of downplaying or mocking the damage caused by the atomic bomb." Weeks later, on December 29, SM Entertainment announced that she would not join the group's Kōhaku performance due to health issues. aespa performed without her.

The suffering of Hiroshima and Nagasaki is real and sacred, and the desire to protect its memory is right. But it is worth noticing how quickly an old, ambiguous post became a public trial, and how little room there was in that trial for the person at its center.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church has unusually precise language for this. It warns against rash judgment: assuming, "without sufficient foundation, the moral fault of a neighbor" (CCC 2477). And it asks something demanding of all of us:

"To avoid rash judgment, everyone should be careful to interpret insofar as possible his neighbor's thoughts, words, and deeds in a favorable way."

Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2478

This is not a rule about celebrities. It is a rule about neighbors, and in the age of the internet, the woman on the other side of the screen is our neighbor too. Online outrage often feels righteous to those who join it. But righteousness that will not pause to ask what someone meant, or to remember that she is a human being, is not justice. It is a crowd.

Rest Is Not Failure

We do not know the details of the health issues that kept Ningning off the Kōhaku stage, and we should not guess. Privacy is part of dignity. But the moment invites a broader reflection, because the idol industry, like much of modern life, is built on the idea that a person should always be available, always performing, always on.

Scripture says otherwise. After a season of conflict and fear, the prophet Elijah collapsed under a broom tree, exhausted and ready to give up. God did not lecture him. An angel brought him bread and water and let him sleep, and only then sent him on (1 Kings 19:4–8). The Sabbath itself is a command to stop, not as a reward for productivity, but because human beings are not made to run without ceasing.

Stepping back from a stage, for whatever reason, is not a moral failure. Sometimes it is the most responsible thing a person can do. And the people who love an artist should want her to rest when she needs to, more than they want her to perform.

Ningning standing on stage in a green camouflage crop top, with a headset microphone, against a pink backdrop

Ningning at SMTOWN, January 2025. Photo: snow plumflower, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Between Two Homes

Ningning is a Chinese artist who built her career in South Korea and performs for audiences around the world, including in Japan. Any artist who works across borders carries more than her own name. She can become, in the eyes of strangers, a stand-in for an entire country, praised or blamed for histories and politics she did not create.

We should be careful not to put words in her mouth about how that feels. But we can recognize the pattern, because it is an old one. People are reduced to categories (nationality, ethnicity, religion) and then judged as categories rather than met as persons.

The Christian vision cuts against that reduction at the root. Each person is created individually, known by name, and loved for herself:

"I praise you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made."

Psalm 139:14

Not "fearfully and wonderfully made as a representative of my nation." Not "as a brand." Simply made: one particular person, from one particular city, with one particular voice, held in being by a God who sees all of her.

What We Owe the People We Watch

Most of us will never meet Ningning. But all of us live, in some way, with other selves: the profile we curate, the reputation we guard, the version of ourselves we perform at work or online. And all of us are, at times, spectators who forget that the people we watch are real.

Her story suggests a few simple practices for anyone who loves music, follows public figures, or spends time online:

Meeting Another Self

aespa's concept promised "meeting another self." In a sense, the Christian life promises the same, though not through an avatar. It is the slow discovery of the self God intended: truer, freer, and more loved than any image the world could design.

Ningning has given millions of people songs to sing along to, stages to remember, and, in a few unguarded moments, the gift of her honesty. The best thing we can give her in return is to see her the way we hope to be seen: not as a concept, not as a controversy, and not as an avatar, but as a person.

The Lord looks on the heart. So should we.

Watch: "I Love You But I Gotta Let You Go"

Ningning performing her solo stage, "I Love You But I Gotta Let You Go," on aespa's SYNK : COMPLAeXITY tour.

Video: MoonCake on YouTube.


Cover photo: Ningning at the SYNK : PARALLEL LINE encore concert, March 2025, by plumflower snow, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Biographical details are drawn from public reporting compiled on Wikipedia.

S

Shirley Xu

Writer exploring the intersection of faith, wellness, and creative living.


Continue Reading

Newsletter

Words for the quiet moments

A letter from Mind & Spirit, delivered occasionally — new essays, reflections, and what's been nourishing lately.